The pair were arrested on Oct. 3 and charged with one felony count of unlawfully taking an alligator, TCPalm reported.
Authorities were tipped off about the illegal treatment of the animal by a complaint from a source to the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission. Video of the incident was reportedly taken and shared.
Kepke admitted to being the man in the video on Sept. 17 but told officers he was not drunk during the incident. He told officers he and Osborne released the alligator alive.
If convicted, the two could face fines and possible jail time.